Most peanut butter is a sugar-and-palm-oil smoothie. Real sugar free peanut butter is boring in the best way: peanuts. Maybe salt. That's it.
Shop: spreads · Once Again review · Once Again vs Barney Butter.
What to look for
- No added sugar (not "low sugar")
- No palm oil
- Short ingredient list
- Protein ~7–8g+ per serving
1. Once Again creamy — Best overall
Organic, lightly salted, no palm oil. Daily driver jar.
SpreadsOnce Again
Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Organic creamy peanut butter without added sugar or palm oil. Lightly salted, clean high-protein spread.
Est. Price$9.99
Buy Now2. Once Again crunchy — Best texture
Same clean formula with crunch. Gym snack champion.
SpreadsOnce Again
Once Again Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter
Crunchy organic peanut butter — peanuts only, no sugar, no palm oil. Ideal daily jar.
Est. Price$10.99
Buy Now3. Want almonds instead?
Once Again and Barney Butter cover clean almond butter without sugar bombs.
SpreadsOnce Again
Once Again Organic Creamy Almond Butter
Organic almond butter with a short label — no added sugar, no palm oil. Cleaner spread for toast and smoothies.
Est. Price$23.98
Buy Now
SpreadsBarney Butter
Barney Butter Smooth Almond Butter
Ultra-smooth almond butter without palm oil or cane sugar. Blanched almonds for a mild, spreadable texture.
Est. Price$10.83
Buy NowWhat we skip
| Skip | Why |
|---|---|
| "Natural" PB with sugar #2 | Still a dessert |
| Palm oil stabilizers | Dirty fat filler |
| Chocolate PB spreads | Usually sugar-loaded |
Bottom line
If the label is longer than peanuts + salt, put it back. Once Again is the clean default.